Ask a BHPH dealer how collections is doing and you'll usually get two numbers: dollars collected and delinquency percentage. Both are real. Both are lagging indicators — they describe a quarter that's already decided.
The metrics below are the ones that tell you what's about to happen, roughly in order of how badly they're neglected.
1. Promise-keep rate
What it is: of the promises to pay your collectors secured, what percentage were actually kept, on the promised date, for the promised amount.
This is the most under-tracked number in BHPH collections and the most diagnostic. A collector can generate impressive PTP volume all day by accepting any promise a customer offers. If the keep rate is 30%, that collector isn't collecting — they're scheduling disappointment and inflating their own activity numbers.
Track it by collector. The spread between your best and worst collector on promise-keep rate will tell you more about who can actually close than any dollar total, because dollar totals are contaminated by which accounts each person was assigned.
2. Right-party contact (RPC) rate
What it is: of the attempts you made, what percentage reached the actual account holder — not a voicemail, not a wrong number, not a relative.
Dial counts are vanity. A collector making 200 attempts a day with an RPC rate of 4% is having eight real conversations. Another making 90 attempts at 15% is having thirteen. The second collector looks lazy on the activity report and is outperforming the first.
Be suspicious of any vendor quoting a very high contact rate. Real BHPH right-party contact rates on outbound tend to sit in the single digits to low teens. Anything dramatically above that usually means the denominator has been quietly redefined.
3. Inbound answer rate and missed-call rate
What it is: of the calls coming to you, how many got answered by a human.
This is the most commonly ignored metric in the entire function, and often the largest single leak. Your phone system already tracks it. Most dealers have simply never pulled the report.
For scale: in one portfolio we measured, the missed-call rate ran 12.5% before an operational change and 3.8% after. On roughly 8,500 inbound calls a month, that's the difference between missing about 1,060 calls and missing about 320 — around 740 additional conversations per month with customers who were already calling.
4. Abandonment rate
What it is: callers who reached your queue and hung up before anyone picked up.
Distinct from missed calls and worse, psychologically. An abandoned caller made the decision to call, waited, and then gave up. Some fraction never call back. In the same portfolio, abandonment ran 12.9% before and 8.5% after.
Watch abandonment against time-of-day. It will almost always spike at the same two or three hours — and those hours are a staffing decision, not a mystery.
5. Roll rate by bucket
What it is: the percentage of accounts moving from each delinquency bucket to the next worse one, month over month.
This is your early warning system. Total delinquency percentage can hold flat while the composition rots underneath it — the 1–30 bucket improving while 60+ quietly fills. Roll rate catches that months before the aggregate does.
Track 0→30, 30→60, 60→90 and 90+→charge-off separately. The 30→60 roll is usually the most actionable: those accounts are still reachable and still emotionally recoverable.
6. Cost per dollar collected
What it is: total fully loaded collections cost divided by total dollars collected.
The single best number for comparing any two ways of doing collections — in-house, outsourced, or a mix. It normalizes across headcount, portfolio size and season.
Fully loaded means fully loaded: wages, payroll burden, benefits, recruiting, training, software seats, phone, and a real slice of management time. Most dealers compute this using wages alone and understate their true cost by 40–60%.
7. Channel mix of collected dollars
What it is: how much money arrives through self-service (portal, IVR, autopay, cash locations) versus a human collector.
This one reliably surprises people. In one portfolio month we analyzed, 47% of collections arrived through automated channels rather than a collector. If half your money arrives without human involvement, then payment-channel friction is a collections strategy, and your portal being confusing is a collections problem.
8. Autopay enrollment rate
What it is: percentage of active accounts on recurring automatic payment.
The most durable thing a collector can accomplish on a call, and it shows up in none of this month's numbers. An account moved to autopay stops consuming collections labor every single month thereafter. In the portfolio we measured, autopay dollars rose 40.8% per day after an operational change — the least dramatic-looking number in the analysis and probably the most valuable long-term.
9. QA score, and the failures behind it
What it is: a structured review of what was actually said on calls, scored against a documented rubric.
The score itself matters less than the failure categories underneath it. Real things surfaced by call-level QA: promises logged that the customer never made, disclosures skipped under time pressure, bots mispronouncing customer names badly enough to destroy credibility in the first three seconds, and payment arrangements agreed to that violated the dealer's own policy.
None of that appears in any dollar metric. All of it eventually does.
A workable reporting cadence
| Frequency | Watch |
|---|---|
| Daily | Inbound answer rate, abandonment, dollars collected |
| Weekly | RPC rate, promise-keep rate by collector, QA exceptions |
| Monthly | Roll rates by bucket, channel mix, autopay enrollment, cost per dollar collected |
If you want a rough sense of what your inbound gap and capacity gap look like before you pull any reports, our collections leak calculator runs entirely in your browser on benchmarks measured in a live portfolio.
See what this looks like on your portfolio
Fifteen minutes on Teams. We'll look at your delinquency, show you real AI text conversations, and tell you honestly whether we can move your numbers.
Book a walkthrough