Ask any Buy Here Pay Here collections manager about the best stretch of the year and most will say the same thing: tax season. For a lot of customers, the refund is the one lump sum they get all year. It's when a customer who is two payments behind can get current, when a customer who is current can pay ahead, and when a promise that has been pushed back since October finally gets kept.
The dealers who get the most out of that window usually start planning well before the first refund lands. This year there's an extra reason to start early: the way refunds get paid has changed.
What's different about this refund season
Paper refund checks are mostly gone
Under a 2025 executive order on federal payments, the IRS began phasing out paper refund checks for individuals on September 30, 2025. The IRS now says it has generally stopped mailing them, with limited exceptions such as hardship cases and situations where no electronic option exists.
That matters for BHPH customers, because many of them don't have a traditional bank account. According to the IRS, a return filed without direct deposit information is still processed, but the refund can take longer. The IRS mails a letter and then a notice (CP53E) asking the filer to provide account details or explain why they can't. If the filer doesn't respond, the IRS says it will mail a paper check after about six weeks.
The IRS also says that people without a bank account have other options, including certain prepaid debit cards and mobile payment apps that can accept a direct deposit.
In plain terms: some of your customers may get their refund weeks later than they're used to, and some may not know why. A customer who tells you "my refund is coming next week" may honestly believe it, and still be wrong.
Refunds were bigger last season
In the 2026 filing season, the average refund ran roughly 11% higher than the year before, according to IRS filing statistics tracked by the Tax Foundation. Analysts tied the increase to tax law changes for 2025 that weren't reflected in paycheck withholding, so many people were over-withheld. Whether that repeats this season depends on each customer's situation, so don't count on it. It's still a reminder of how much money moves in a few weeks.
Some refunds always come later
By law, the IRS holds refunds that include the Earned Income Tax Credit or the Additional Child Tax Credit until after mid-February. Many BHPH customers claim one of those credits. So the busiest weeks for your customers' refunds tend to come in late February and early March, not January.
What this means for your desk
Put those three facts together and you get a simple picture. The money is real and it's large. It arrives in a short window. And this year, for some customers, it will arrive later than they promised you it would.
The risk isn't that customers won't pay. It's that promises tied to a refund date break, nobody follows up quickly, and the refund gets spent on something else before your desk gets back in touch.
A plan you can start this month
1. Sort your accounts before January
Pull a list of accounts that are behind, accounts that caught up last tax season, and accounts that tend to pay ahead in the spring. Decide what you want from each group: getting current, paying down a deferred balance, or paying ahead.
2. Start the conversation early, and keep it simple
Reach out in early January, before customers have mentally spent the refund. A short, friendly text works well: let them know you'd like to help them get caught up when their refund comes in, and ask when they expect it. That one question gives you a date to plan around and a reason to follow up.
3. Plan for the late refund
When a customer gives you a refund date, treat it as a best guess, not a promise carved in stone. Set a check-in for the day after, and if the money hasn't arrived, ask what happened instead of marking the promise broken and moving on. If the customer mentions a letter from the IRS about their refund, point them to the IRS's own website or the notice itself. Don't give tax advice, and don't try to fix their tax issue for them.
4. Make paying the moment the money lands as easy as possible
The easiest payment to collect is the one the customer can make in thirty seconds from their phone, right when the refund hits. A text with a secure payment link beats asking them to drive to the lot or call during business hours.
5. Get ahead of scam confusion
Refund season is also scam season, and the IRS says it won't text or call people asking for bank details. Make sure your messages are clearly from your dealership, use your dealership's name, and never ask for anything a customer would expect only the IRS to ask for. Customers who trust that your texts are really from you are far more likely to answer.
6. Staff for the spike
Refund season brings a burst of inbound calls and texts: customers asking for their payoff, their balance, or how to pay ahead. If those go to voicemail after hours, some of that money goes somewhere else. Decide now who handles the surge, including nights and weekends.
How Peak helps during tax season
Most of this plan comes down to reaching people and following up on time, at a volume a small desk struggles to keep up with in February. That's what Peak is built for.
Peak's AI texting reaches customers who won't answer the phone. Across our dealers, about 40% of texts get a reply, compared with about 3% of outbound calls reaching the customer. That's about 13× more responses by text. Peak can start the refund conversation with every account on your list in January, ask when the refund is expected, and set the follow-up automatically. Customers can pay by card on the spot through PayNearMe.
If a refund date comes and goes, Peak checks in the next day and keeps the conversation going until there's a payment or a new plan. AI voice agents answer inbound calls around the clock, so the customer who calls on a Saturday night with a refund in hand gets an answer and a way to pay. One of our Account Resolution Specialists steps in when an account needs a person. Your contact hours, cadence and disclosures are set to your policy, and 100% of notes post to your DMS automatically, whether that's IDMS, AMS or eMotive.
Refund season only comes once a year. The dealers who plan for it in November are the ones who don't spend March wondering where the money went.
Sources
- IRS: Questions and answers about Executive Order 14247 (paper refund check phase-out)
- IRS: IRS to phase out paper tax refund checks starting with individual taxpayers
- Tax Foundation: What IRS data shows about the 2026 filing season
See what this looks like on your portfolio
Fifteen minutes on Teams. We'll look at your delinquency, show you real AI text conversations, and tell you honestly whether we can move your numbers.
Book a walkthrough